3 Best Pizza in Sheffield, UK

Expert-recommended Top 3 Pizza in Sheffield, UK. All of our pizza places actually undergo a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes local reviews, history, business standards, ratings, satisfaction, trust, price and their trading excellence. You deserve only the best!

Proove Pizza
Proove Pizza
Proove Pizza
10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL CONTACT

PROOVE PIZZA

261 Fulwood Road, Broomhill, Sheffield S10 3BD, UK Directions

Since 2015

Speciality:

Marinara Margherita Americana Pesto Royale Vesuvio Funghi Ortolana Neptuna Diavola Melanzane Quattro Stagioni San Daniele Rucola Giardino Caprese Chocolate Brownie Gelato or Sorbet Tropical Twist Fizzy Apple Zing Fruit Cooler Bel Paese Verdure Calzone Vegetable Calzone

Proove Pizza restaurant seeks fresh and high-quality ingredients from local sources to make simple, flavour-rich pizza. Their dough is made with only the best Italian 00-grade Caputo flour, slow-proved for 20 hours, hand-stretched, topped with the finest ingredients, and cooked to perfection. Proove Pizza restaurant makes a pizza revolution to deliver consistent, affordable pizza at the lowest cost. The pizzeria features a warm and comfortable environment for customers to dine in. They provide vegan and gluten-free menus. They offer happy hour menus.

2025 Update: Proove Pizza serving you award-winning, authentic pizza & small plates. The restaurant has locations in Manchester, Broomhill, and Orchard Square.

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

Marinara £9.4 Margherita £10.8 Pepperoni Doppio £14.2 Pesto Royale £14.7 Diavola £14.8 Funghi £12.8 Ortolana £12.4 Tonno £14.3 Melanzane £12.4 Olives £4 DOUGH BITES REG £4.5 LG £6.5 Garlic Bread £6.2 Garlic Bread with Mozzarella £7.8 Garlic Bread with Balsamic & Tomato £7.5 Antipasti Carni £13.6 Antipasti Verdure £12.5 Burrata £7.9

Contact:

01142 945 185

Mon-Thu & Sun: 11:30am - 10pm
Fri & Sat: 11:30am - 10:30pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Rudy's Pizza Napoletana
Rudy's Pizza Napoletana
Rudy's Pizza Napoletana
CALL CONTACT

RUDY'S PIZZA NAPOLETANA

40 - 44 Divison Street, Sheffield S1 4GF, UK Directions

Speciality:

Marinara Doppia Mozzarella White Tarantina Agnello Vegano Tonno Cinghiale Romagnola Margherita Margherita Con Bufala Portobello Salame Calabrese Triple Pepperoni Salsiccia Capricciosa Carni

Rudy's Pizza Napoletana has a warm and cosy atmosphere. They provide a wide range of menus including pizza, pasta and salads. All their staff are amiable and support all the customers' needs. The restaurant also has vegan and gluten-free menus. They provide facilities with free wifi and delivery services. Enjoy your favourite Rudy's Pizzas delivered straight to your door with their online website. Come and enjoy their mouth-watering dishes with family and friends. They provide outdoor seating areas for their beloved customers.

2025 Update: Rudy's Pizza Napoletana offers vegetarian options on its menu and has Disabled toilets for customers' convenience. The restaurant provides Wi-Fi connectivity for additional entertainment. They offer gift cards to have vibrant flavours on any occasion.

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

Marinara £8.5
Margherita Con Bufala £12.9
Tarantina £11.9
Calabrese £11.9
Triple Pepperoni £14.5
Carni £13.9
Capricciosa £13.9
'Nduja Ortolana £13.5
Margherita £9.9
Doppia Mozzarella £12.5
Portobello £11.9
Salame £11.9
Cinghiale £12.9
Salsiccia £12.9
Tonno £12.9
Romagnola £13.9
DIPS
Garlic Aioli £2
Chilli Honey Dip £2
'Nduja Aioli £2
All Three Dips £5.5

Contact:

0114 299 2550

Mon-Wed & Sun: 12pm - 9:30pm
Thu-Sat: 12pm - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

The Porter Pizza Company
The Porter Pizza Company
The Porter Pizza Company
6+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL CONTACT

THE PORTER PIZZA COMPANY

394-396 Sharrow Vale Road, Hunters Bar, Sheffield S118ZP, UK Directions

Speciality:

Margherita Pizza Bufala Pizza Marinara Pizza Shroom Raider Pizza Alpine Goat Pizza Meltdown Pizza Parmigiana Pizza Simply Salami Honey Pie The H.o.m. Flamin’ Nora Amore Neapolitan Shroom Raider and Fennel Seed Salami

The Porter Pizza Company is one of the best pizza restaurants in Sheffield. The outstanding pizza restaurant is known for its artisanal, handcrafted pizzas. They provide a comfortable dining space that can accommodate up to 34 guests, and during the summer months, there's an additional table available outside. Their dough-making process begins in-house, utilising a slow fermentation technique, and the dough is then meticulously shaped into dough balls by hand. These dough balls are hand-stretched to form the pizza base and adorned with the finest ingredients from artisan Italian and local suppliers. What sets their pizzas apart is their rapid cooking time of 60-90 seconds in a scorching 400-degree wood-fired oven, resulting in the distinctive puffed crust that pizza enthusiasts adore. Each pizza is crafted with genuine love and unwavering commitment to a never-ending quest for perfection.

2025 Update: The Porter Pizza Company offers gift cards for its customers and has a range of soft drinks, Italian lagers, local beers, salads, olives and homemade desserts, including its real homemade gelato. They also provide vegan options.

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

Vegetarian Pizza
Margherita £9.00
Alpine Goat £12.00
Smokey Jean £12.50
Gold Rush Veggie £13.00
Forager £11.50
Vegan Pizza
Vegan Margherita £8.50
Marinara £9.00
Vegan Parmigiana £12.50
Vegan Forager £11.50
Meat & Seafood Pizza
Simply Salami £11.00
Honey Pie £13.00
H.O.M. £13.00
Flamin’ Nora £13.00
Neapolitan £10.00 - £14.00
La Maghrebine (Special) £14.00
Gold Rush Meat £13.00
Crudo £13.00
Garlic Bread
Tomato Garlic Bread £7.00
Cheesy Garlic Bread £8.00
Chilli Garlic Bread £8.00
Nduja Garlic Bread £9.00

Contact:

0114 267 6672

Mon-Thu: 5pm - 9pm
Fri: 5pm - 9:30pm
Sat: 12pm - 9:30pm
Sun: 12pm - 9pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you agree to our Privacy Policy.